Two Miami-Dade retail properties, $4.77 million off the 2026 roll in 15 days

A private owner of two South Florida retail properties got 2026 notices that pushed values up on buildings that had not changed. We filed in the first week of the window and both properties settled with the Property Appraiser, without a hearing.

$4.77Mtaken off the 2026 market value
~$93,600first-year tax savings
15 daysfrom filing to signed settlement
At a glance
  • Client: a private owner of retail real estate in South Florida. Details withheld for confidentiality.
  • Properties: a multi-tenant power center in south Miami-Dade and a single-tenant big-box store in north Miami-Dade.
  • 2026 notices: $62.77 million combined market value.
  • Filed: September 1, 2026, in the first week of the 25-day petition window.
  • Settled: September 16, 2026, with the Miami-Dade Property Appraiser. No hearing.

The notices

Both properties got 2026 TRIM notices in August with higher values than 2025. Nothing about either property had changed. There were no permits, no additions and no renovations of record. The increases came from the county’s numbers, not from the buildings.

The owner asked us to look at both before the September petition deadline. We filed petitions for both on September 1 and sent the Property Appraiser an income-approach package for each one the same week. Filing early mattered. It gave the appraiser’s staff time to review the evidence and make an offer before the VAB calendar filled up.

Property 1: a power center valued like a vacant lot

This is an 18-acre center of about 250,000 square feet, in buildings from the 1970s and 2000. It has a discount anchor, a fitness anchor, an off-price junior anchor and several outparcels, all leased and operating.

The 2026 notice put the market value at $41.77 million. Two-thirds of that, $27.8 million, was the land line. A land value that large only makes sense if a buyer would tear the center down and redevelop the site. Nobody buys a fully leased center that way. They buy the income.

So we valued it on its income. We took the center’s actual 2025 operating statements, prepared by the owner’s outside accountants, and normalized two lines: management at a market rate, and a standard reserve for replacements. We capitalized the result at a rate taken from published 1Q 2026 investor surveys for this kind of center, then applied the 15% adjustment Florida law requires for costs of sale. We also gave the appraiser a sensitivity grid that moved the income and the cap rate in both directions. Every result in the grid was below the notice.

The appraiser’s income specialist reviewed the package and wrote that the data supports a reduction. The county cut the building value by $2.77 million and left the land line where it was. The 2026 market value went from $41.77 million to $39.0 million.

Property 2: a 30-year-old building that kept getting more valuable

This is a three-story, single-tenant big-box store of about 165,000 square feet, built in the mid-1990s on an industrially zoned site.

The land value had not moved in three years. The building value had: it went up 26% from 2024 to 2026, on a building about 30 years old with no improvements on record. The 2026 notice put the total at $21.0 million.

A three-story box with elevators is a hard space to lease. Very few retailers want it, and it is bigger than any big-box lease in the regional rent surveys we used. We valued it as if it were leased at market rent, using the same worksheet conventions a neighboring county’s appraiser had used on a comparable store: stabilized vacancy, landlord expenses on a net lease, and the 15% statutory adjustment. Again, every scenario in our sensitivity grid came in below the notice. The 2024 value was higher than the whole grid, which told us the building was already fully assessed before the two increases.

The county revised the building value to keep it in line with the prior year. The 2026 market value went from $21.0 million to $19.0 million.

The result

Property2026 noticeSettledReductionFirst-year tax savings
Power center$41,770,000$39,000,000$2,770,000 (6.6%)~$49,000
Big-box store$21,000,000$19,000,000$2,000,000 (9.5%)~$44,700
Total$62,770,000$58,000,000$4,770,000 (7.6%)~$93,600

Tax savings use each property’s 2026 combined millage from its TRIM notice: about 17.7 mills for the power center and about 22.3 mills for the store, which sits in a city with a higher municipal rate. That is why a smaller reduction on the store is worth almost as much as the larger one on the center. Both settlements were signed on September 16, which closed both appeals for 2026.

What an owner can take from this

  • Read the building line, not just the total. If the building value went up and nothing was built, ask why. On an older building that is often the easiest part of the notice to challenge.
  • Check how much of the value is land. When land is most of the total on an operating property, the county may be valuing the site, not the business that is actually there.
  • Know your own numbers before you share them. Actual income helped on the center. On a different property it could hurt. Decide what you hand over before the appraiser asks for it.
  • File early. Both of these settled informally because the evidence reached the appraiser while there was still time to review it.

How Reserve handles this

Levy, our agentic AI, reads every TRIM notice in a portfolio, compares each value with market evidence and flags the parcels worth petitioning. Reserve Tax Group files the petitions, builds the evidence and negotiates with the appraiser. If a case goes to a hearing, we handle that too. Read more about how Florida TRIM notices work and how an appeal works, step by step.

Values come from the Miami-Dade Property Appraiser’s signed 2026 Valuation Interview Reports. Tax savings are estimates based on the 2026 proposed millage on each property’s TRIM notice; final taxes depend on adopted rates. Client and property details have been withheld or generalized to protect confidentiality. Every property is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Own property in Florida? Check it before next August.

Send your parcels. We will flag the ones worth petitioning before the 2027 TRIM notices go out. The review is free.

Scan your portfolio
Newsletter

Get the next one by email.

One email a month on property tax law changes and filing windows, plus a reminder when a deadline in your state is close. Unsubscribe anytime.

Where you own property (optional)
Keep reading